[Acks]

6/10. The focal isn't really defined and there is way too much going on. The light source is a bit strong as well. May work better as an abstract.

[mopman94]

9/10 I love it

[Wolverine]

dont like the text, and it looks like it could have been better-but very nice :D 7.9/10

[mopman94]

which is the sig? :shock:

[Final Keyblade]

text looks bad and the ship looks a tad LQ 7/10

[iamwyatt4life]

1st: Looks good but empty space could be filled better. 9/10
2nd: Colors good, concept and flow are pretty good, but kind of looks like he's just floating. 8.5/10

[MadBacker]

The person in the tag makes in awesome. Morgan Freeman FTW. The lighting ins nice,and I really like the text. I'm not sure what the effects around him are(displacement?) but I found them distracting (Just IMO, don't know how others feel) 7.5/10

[iamwyatt4life]

You got your critiques on your first signature in your recent thread. ^_^
As for the second one, Lighting is missing, good flow, colors are pretty good. 8/10

[Wolverine]

9/10 like it but...the c4d on the right is kinda distracting


next person rate this:


from tut^^

[Acks]

4/10 Very messy and the focal isn't blended well. The right is a bit blank as well.

[MadBacker]

Little flow, I think the text is too big and the lighting is alright. The colors are nice and it has a well defined focal point. 6/10

[saviourking120]

#1: 6/10: Some of the effects are too obvious, and the coloring isnt good.
#2: 7/10: Good flow, ans the texture looks cool.

Rate/class this one.

[mopman94]

Nice not much lighting though 7/10

Next person rate this (I made it for someone in anouther forum):

[Kiba]

6.7/10
I like the atmosphere, but not the blur.
text is great though.

[saviourking120]

#1: 8.5/10: The concept is sweet, the blurring looks a little forced
#2: 8/10: The effect execution is awesome, but has way too much dead space.

Rate this one from a while back!

[Terroth]

Is that from one of Geocillins tutorials?
The text aaaah!
The Border!!!
lol, its not bad though 7/10
And your current 8.95/10 :D

[Wolverine]

lol i had to look twice about what was going on but its a cool sig! solid 8/10

next person rate these 2 sigs

...i kinda suck at these


the only thing i'm actually good at....

[Nami~san]

1st: The blending is pretty good but the text placement doesnt looks not so good. Background needs more things in it and fg effects maybe. 6/10

2nd: I love The effect but a bit more glossy shine on the red middle and the side blue bars. 8/10

[Dracius]

7/10 Use different font and put text on the left. Also, get rid of the bit on the left, it doesn't suit it. Other than that a great sig :D

Rate all three, this and the ones in my signature:

[mopman94]

I like them are those C4D's?

8/10